Proof and Evidence , BHARATIYA SAKSHYA ADHINIYAM, 2023

Proof and Evidence

Proof and Evidence are two terms that have different meanings and implications in the context of the THE BHARATIYA SAKSHYA ADHINIYAM, 2023 (the Act). Here is a brief explanation of the difference between proof and evidence with special reference to the Act:

Evidence 

- Evidence refers to information or facts that help us to establish the truth or existence of something. Evidence can be of two types: oral evidence, which includes statements made by witnesses relevant to the matter under inquiry and presented with court authorization, and documentary evidence, which comprises documents, whether physical or electronic, submitted to the court for examination. Evidence can also be classified as direct evidence, which offers clear and conclusive proof of a fact without the need for interpretation, and indirect evidence, which requires inference or presumption to prove a fact. Evidence can be strong or weak, conclusive or inconclusive, depending on the quality and quantity of the information. Evidence can also be challenged, contradicted, or refuted by other evidence.

Proof

- Proof is the sum of evidence which helps to prove something. Proof is more concrete and conclusive than evidence. Proof shows that a statement, a fact, or a claim is true beyond any doubt. Proof can be used in legal or scientific contexts, where a high level of certainty is required. Proof is usually the result of a logical argument, a mathematical demonstration, or an empirical test. Proof is not subject to dispute or revision, unless there is an error or a fraud. Proof can also be classified as primary proof, which pertains to original documents or firsthand information, and secondary proof, which involves copies of documents or hearsay information, admissible in court under specific conditions.

The Act provides various provisions for determining the relevancy, admissibility, and sufficiency of evidence and proof in legal proceedings. The Act also defines the terms "may presume", "shall presume", and "conclusive proof" to indicate the degree of force or effect of certain facts or evidence on the proof of other facts or evidence. The Act also lays down the rules for the burden of proof, the competency and examination of witnesses, the production and effect of evidence, and the presumption as to documents.